{
  "standard": "Algorithmic Transparency Standard",
  "standard_version": "0.3.1",
  "schema": "https://standaard.algoritmeregister.org/schemas/registration-v0.3.1.schema.json",
  "complete": true,
  "to_fill": [],
  "entries": [
    {
      "name": "The staff rule reader (spells)",
      "description_short": "Reads a booking rule that City staff write in Greek and drafts it as a Cedar policy with its legal basis; staff review it, replay it against past events and activate it. It never activates a rule itself.",
      "organization": "AGORA prototype for the City of Athens (Apps4Athens 3.0)",
      "department": "AGORA team (a prototype; not a City department)",
      "contact_email": "ioanniscatargiu@outlook.com",
      "contact_phone": null,
      "contact_name": null,
      "area": "City of Athens",
      "domain": "culture, sports and leisure",
      "website": null,
      "status": "development",
      "remark": "A prototype built for the Apps4Athens 3.0 hackathon; not an official City of Athens system. The risk category is the prototype's own reading, to be checked with the City's DPO and lawyers before any pilot.",
      "decision_making_process": "Staff write a rule in Greek on the staff page. The model proposes a Cedar policy and the provision it rests on. Deterministic checks then validate it against the City's policy schema and the verified legal corpus. Staff replay it against past events and activate it, two different members when two-person activation is on. Nothing takes effect without that human activation.",
      "goal": "Let City staff change a booking rule in their own words, with a reviewable, versioned and signed policy as the result.",
      "impact": "An activated rule changes which bookings of municipal sports spaces are allowed. Every activation is a signed, append-only policy version with a receipt; a refused booking names the rule and its legal basis.",
      "risks": "A misread rule could allow or refuse the wrong bookings. Mitigated by human review, replay before activation, schema validation, matching the legal basis against verified provisions, and a labelled fixed-rule reader when the model is unavailable.",
      "risk_category": "limited risk",
      "proportionality": "Only the rule's text, the policy schema and the regulation's values reach the model; no personal data. Staff remain the decision makers.",
      "lawful_basis": "None loaded for the prototype. The rules it drafts must each rest on a provision of the verified corpus, or say that none is loaded. A pilot needs the City's own basis for using the reader.",
      "documentation": null,
      "training_data": "Not trained by AGORA. A general-purpose model from Anthropic, used through its API; its training data is the provider's.",
      "source_data": "The rule text staff write, the City's Cedar policy schema, and the regulation's values (catalog/regulation.yaml).",
      "data_bias": null,
      "connected_data_sources": "None at run time beyond the policy schema and the regulation; a replay reads the City's own past events.",
      "DPIA_description": null,
      "DPIA_url": null,
      "algorithm_type": "hybrid",
      "description": "A large language model drafts Cedar from Greek text; deterministic code (schema validation, legal-basis matching, replay) decides whether the draft can be activated, and a person activates it.",
      "methods_and_models": "Anthropic Claude (claude-opus-5-5, pinned) through one model interface (agora/model.py); Cedar policies (cedarpy 4.12.2).",
      "performance": "Latency p95 6.66 s on the 71 rule cases (owner's measurement, 29 Oct). Accuracy figures are not published here.",
      "alternatives_considered": "A fixed-rule reader without a model (used, and labelled, when no model key is set). ILSP's Llama-Krikri-8B as a local model, not used until it passes the same cases.",
      "product_information": null,
      "codebase_url": null,
      "product_page": null,
      "AIA_description": null,
      "AIA_url": null,
      "monitoring": "Every model call is logged (model id, purpose, prompt version); every activation is a signed policy version with a receipt.",
      "type": "prescriptive",
      "human_intervention": "Staff review and activate every rule; the model cannot activate one. Two-person activation is on by default.",
      "objection_procedure": "A refused booking names its rule and legal basis; the person can ask the City's staff. The prototype has no formal objection procedure.",
      "rollback": "A new policy version replaces the active one; versions are append-only and their receipts keep the history.",
      "standard_version": "0.3.1",
      "uuid": null,
      "lang": "en",
      "publication_date": "2026-11-21",
      "last_change_date": "2026-11-21",
      "revision_date": "2027-02-21",
      "revision_note": null,
      "keywords": "rules, Cedar, staff, Greek, language model"
    },
    {
      "name": "The City's assistant (planner and extractor)",
      "description_short": "Answers a person's question about the City by planning reads of the City's public tools, and proposes a booking, a cancellation or a withdrawal that runs only when the person approves its exact hash.",
      "organization": "AGORA prototype for the City of Athens (Apps4Athens 3.0)",
      "department": "AGORA team (a prototype; not a City department)",
      "contact_email": "ioanniscatargiu@outlook.com",
      "contact_phone": null,
      "contact_name": null,
      "area": "City of Athens",
      "domain": "government",
      "website": null,
      "status": "development",
      "remark": "A prototype; not an official City of Athens system. It has no powers beyond the tools any agent gets. The risk category is the prototype's own reading, to be checked before any pilot.",
      "decision_making_process": "The model plans which read tools to call, in at most 6 turns and 8 tool calls; upstream text reaches it only as handles, never as raw text. It can propose a write, stored with a nonce and a hash; the write runs once, through the personal tools' own path, only when the person approves that exact hash.",
      "goal": "Help people without an agent of their own find what the City offers and act on it, with the same limits any agent has.",
      "impact": "It shows information and proposes actions; a booking or a cancellation happens only after the person's approval.",
      "risks": "A wrong or incomplete answer, or a proposal the person did not intend. Mitigated by source names in every answer, handles instead of untrusted text, a closed extraction schema, and approval of the exact plan.",
      "risk_category": "limited risk",
      "proportionality": "Only the person's question and the tools' typed fields reach the model; strings from upstream sources reach it as handles. The assistant acts under the person's own mandate, with that mandate's scopes.",
      "lawful_basis": "None loaded for the prototype; a pilot needs the City's own basis and a DPIA.",
      "documentation": null,
      "training_data": "Not trained by AGORA. A general-purpose model from Anthropic, used through its API; its training data is the provider's.",
      "source_data": "The person's question, and the answers of the City's own read tools (each with its source).",
      "data_bias": null,
      "connected_data_sources": "The City's public read tools (open data, decisions, procedures, spaces, partner data), through the same catalogue as every agent.",
      "DPIA_description": null,
      "DPIA_url": null,
      "algorithm_type": "hybrid",
      "description": "A language model plans and extracts; deterministic code checks every tool call, holds every proposal and runs it only on approval.",
      "methods_and_models": "Anthropic Claude through one model interface (agora/model.py); a closed extraction schema; a bounded loop.",
      "performance": null,
      "alternatives_considered": "The person's own agent (any assistant, through the same tools); the counter, 1595 and the forms.",
      "product_information": null,
      "codebase_url": null,
      "product_page": null,
      "AIA_description": null,
      "AIA_url": null,
      "monitoring": "Every model call is logged (model id, purpose, prompt version); every write is a receipt in the City's hash-chained ledger.",
      "type": "prescriptive",
      "human_intervention": "The person approves the exact plan before anything is written; they can revoke the mandate at any time.",
      "objection_procedure": "Every action has a receipt; the person can cancel or withdraw, or ask the City's staff. No formal procedure in the prototype.",
      "rollback": "A booking can be cancelled and a request withdrawn by the person; receipts keep the history.",
      "standard_version": "0.3.1",
      "uuid": null,
      "lang": "en",
      "publication_date": "2026-11-21",
      "last_change_date": "2026-11-21",
      "revision_date": "2027-02-21",
      "revision_note": null,
      "keywords": "assistant, agents, planning, approval, receipts"
    },
    {
      "name": "The allocation draw for scarce spaces",
      "description_short": "When more groups ask for a municipal space than it can hold, a published rule set and a public random beacon decide the allocation; anyone can recompute the draw from public data.",
      "organization": "AGORA prototype for the City of Athens (Apps4Athens 3.0)",
      "department": "AGORA team (a prototype; not a City department)",
      "contact_email": "ioanniscatargiu@outlook.com",
      "contact_phone": null,
      "contact_name": null,
      "area": "City of Athens",
      "domain": "culture, sports and leisure",
      "website": null,
      "status": "development",
      "remark": "A prototype; not an official City of Athens system. Allocating public spaces may need a stricter category; the prototype's reading is to be checked before any pilot.",
      "decision_making_process": "Staff open a round; requests are collected; at the close, the versioned allocation rules (each resting on whole sentences of the verified corpus) and a constraint solver allocate the spaces, with ties broken by the drand beacon's randomness. Staff run the round on the staff page; the result is published to the City's feed.",
      "goal": "Allocate scarce municipal spaces by rules everyone can read, with a draw anyone can check.",
      "impact": "Decides which groups get which slots in a round; every allocation is published and receipted.",
      "risks": "An unfair rule, or a result people cannot check. Mitigated by published, versioned rules with their legal basis, a public randomness source, and a recomputation anyone can run (verify/verify_draw.py).",
      "risk_category": "limited risk",
      "proportionality": "Only the requests and the rules enter the draw; no profiling, no model, no personal data beyond the requesting group.",
      "lawful_basis": "Each allocation rule names whole sentences of a provision in the verified corpus (catalog/allocation_rules.yaml).",
      "documentation": null,
      "training_data": "None. No model is trained or used.",
      "source_data": "The round's requests, the spaces' registry (catalog/spaces.yaml) and the allocation rules.",
      "data_bias": null,
      "connected_data_sources": "The drand public randomness beacon.",
      "DPIA_description": null,
      "DPIA_url": null,
      "algorithm_type": "rule-based",
      "description": "A constraint solver (OR-Tools CP-SAT) applies the versioned rules; randomness = SHA-256 of the drand round's signature.",
      "methods_and_models": "OR-Tools CP-SAT; drand; the pure allocation module (agora/allocation.py) with no database, network or clock.",
      "performance": null,
      "alternatives_considered": "First come, first served (rewards whoever is fastest); a lottery without rules.",
      "product_information": null,
      "codebase_url": null,
      "product_page": null,
      "AIA_description": null,
      "AIA_url": null,
      "monitoring": "Each round's result and its randomness are published to the City's feed, where verify/verify_draw.py recomputes it.",
      "type": "prescriptive",
      "human_intervention": "Staff open, close and run each round; the rules change only by a new, published version.",
      "objection_procedure": "Anyone can recompute the draw from public data (verify/verify_draw.py); a person can ask the City's staff.",
      "rollback": null,
      "standard_version": "0.3.1",
      "uuid": null,
      "lang": "en",
      "publication_date": "2026-11-21",
      "last_change_date": "2026-11-21",
      "revision_date": "2027-02-21",
      "revision_note": null,
      "keywords": "allocation, lottery, constraint solver, drand, fairness"
    },
    {
      "name": "The City's booking rules and agent tiers",
      "description_short": "Decides, by written rules, whether a booking of a municipal space is allowed and which agents may call which personal tool, and how often; every refusal names its rule.",
      "organization": "AGORA prototype for the City of Athens (Apps4Athens 3.0)",
      "department": "AGORA team (a prototype; not a City department)",
      "contact_email": "ioanniscatargiu@outlook.com",
      "contact_phone": null,
      "contact_name": null,
      "area": "City of Athens",
      "domain": "culture, sports and leisure",
      "website": null,
      "status": "development",
      "remark": "A prototype; not an official City of Athens system.",
      "decision_making_process": "Cedar policies (one permit and one forbid per rule, each with its legal basis) and worded checks both run on every booking; a request is refused if either refuses. The agent-tier policy decides which tier of agent may call which personal tool, with per-minute quotas. No model takes part.",
      "goal": "Apply the City's booking regulation and its limits on agents the same way for everyone, with a reason for every refusal.",
      "impact": "Allows or refuses bookings of municipal sports spaces and agents' calls; every decision is receipted.",
      "risks": "A rule written wrongly. Mitigated by rules as data checked against the verified corpus at boot, tests, and a logged disagreement whenever the two checks differ.",
      "risk_category": "minimal risk",
      "proportionality": "Only the booking's own facts (space, time, group size, purpose) and the agent's tier are read.",
      "lawful_basis": "Each rule names its provision in the verified corpus, or says that none is loaded (catalog/policies/city_rules.cedar).",
      "documentation": null,
      "training_data": "None. No model is trained or used.",
      "source_data": "The booking request, the spaces' registry and the regulation's values (catalog/regulation.yaml).",
      "data_bias": null,
      "connected_data_sources": "None.",
      "DPIA_description": null,
      "DPIA_url": null,
      "algorithm_type": "rule-based",
      "description": "Cedar policies (cedarpy 4.12.2) with the regulation's values as data, and the same rules as worded checks.",
      "methods_and_models": "Cedar; agora/city_policy.py and agora/agent_policy.py.",
      "performance": null,
      "alternatives_considered": "Rules in code only (harder to read and to audit).",
      "product_information": null,
      "codebase_url": null,
      "product_page": null,
      "AIA_description": null,
      "AIA_url": null,
      "monitoring": "Every decision is a receipt; a disagreement between the two checks is logged.",
      "type": "prescriptive",
      "human_intervention": "Staff change the rules only by a new, signed policy version (the rule reader above, reviewed and activated by staff).",
      "objection_procedure": "A refusal names its rule and legal basis and the next step; the person can ask the City's staff.",
      "rollback": "A new policy version replaces the active one.",
      "standard_version": "0.3.1",
      "uuid": null,
      "lang": "en",
      "publication_date": "2026-11-21",
      "last_change_date": "2026-11-21",
      "revision_date": "2027-02-21",
      "revision_note": null,
      "keywords": "rules, Cedar, bookings, agents, quotas"
    }
  ]
}